🔨 Is Being ‘Tough on Crime’ Effective? Here’s What a Criminal Lawyer Thinks
Examining the Law and Order Debate Through a Legal Lens The phrase "tough on crime" is a perennial favourite in political campaigning and media commentary. It promises immediate security through harsher punishments, stricter laws, and longer prison sentences. However, for a criminal defence lawyer, whose career is spent navigating the practical realities and outcomes of the justice system, the effectiveness of this approach is often viewed with deep skepticism. Their perspective is shaped by court data, the principles of sentencing, and the high rate of recidivism (re-offending). I. The Reality Gap: Rhetoric vs. Results Criminal lawyers and criminologists frequently point out a significant "reality gap" between the political rhetoric driving "toughness" and the actual crime statistics across the jurisdictions. 1. The Politicisation of Justice Defence lawyers observe that "tough on crime" policies are often driven by political populism (appealing...